Altadis USA - cigar connoisseur section




Send a cigar postcard
   
  judging cigars

            Cigar Judging Section Volume II

Go back to Volume I

The following topics are covered in this informational section (Click a topic to jump that section).


What Does Fermentation Do To Tobacco?
Is When And Where A Cigar Is Smoked Important?
What's The Best Temperature And Humidity To Store Cigars?
Is The Size Of A Cigar Important To The Taste And Aroma?
What About Price?
Epilogue

Other Connoisseur Links
history
etiquette
construction
size variations
wrapper types
tobacco regions
cigar type suggestions
how to judge a good cigar
The Official Cigar Rating System  

 

What Does Fermentation Do To Tobacco?

In addition to the financial resources enabling a manufacturer to stock up on leaf supply and the expertise in acquiring those stocks, it's imperative that the tobacco be properly processed before use. For all the types which make up a cigar - filler (the guts of a cigar), binder and wrapper - the process known as fermentation must be carefully monitored and completed before the tobacco is rolled into a cigar. After the cigar is made, forget it, fermentation ceases.

Tobacco fermentation means laying the leaves into huge "bulks", the centers of which develop heat. The heat in the center of a bulk should not be allowed to exceed about 115-130 degrees F, depending on the type of tobacco, otherwise it will be ruined, burned out so to speak. When it gets up to that temperature, and it will do so in its own time depending on the leaf and its condition, the bulk gets turned inside out and the heat build up (fermentation) begins again. When the heat levels off, the fermentation is complete. This could occur after four turns or eight turns, referred to as "sweats" in the Trade. Over-fermentation will ruin the leaf, cause it to become "spent" and lose its flavor and aroma.

During "sweating", the fermentation process causes the emission of nitrogen compounds and other chemical compounds and reduces somewhat the nicotine content. After fermentation, further aging in bales helps to settle the leaf and enhances flavor and burning quality. Manufacturers who can't afford to wait or who just don't care to wait until this process is completed, produce inferior cigars.

If, when you smoke your box of 25 cigars, you find the following telltale signs, chances are the leaf has not been fully fermented or aged:

Harshness or bitterness on the tongue, lips and in the mouth. a feeling something like heartburn in the chest cavity. The cigar keeps going out easily. If this happens with a few cigars in your box, the manufacturer is not consistent in the use of his tobaccos. If this happens with a majority of them, he is not making the investment in fully aged leaf. He is using the tobacco before its time.

Now you know something about leaf processing and its importance in producing a consistently high quality cigar. One last point on this subject. Once the cigar is made, it is impossible to ferment the tobacco further. How would it be possible it get the temperature up to 115 degrees F (45 degrees + C.) in order to do the job? Some cigar people say that natural wrapped cigars properly kept in the box without cellophane will "mature" and become more mellow. Maybe, but, if unfermented or "raw" tobacco has been used, no amount of aging or maturing in the box will cure it. Cigar tobacco is not like wine.


Is When And Where A Cigar Is Smoked Important?

Whenever you smoke cigars from a certain box, see if you can determine any significant variance in taste and aroma. If you can, now you know the probable cause. But be careful. A cigar will taste different depending on when it's smoked: morning or evening, after a meal, with coffee, or cognac, indoors or outdoors. Maybe one of the box of 25 isn't sufficient after all to really test for consistent quality. It probably is, but the point is that slight variances are acceptable. It's the wide swing in quality you must watch out for. Remember, the bad cigar costs as much as the good one. You're entitled to some assurance of getting value for your money.


What's The Best Temperature And Humidity To Store Cigars?

If you keep your cigars at 70% relative humidity and 70 degrees F, they'll dry out over a long period of time. To combat this, get a decent humidor, keep the cigars at room temperature, charge the humidifier in the humidor regularly and you'll have no problem. For large walk in humidors, remember that a manufacturer equilibrates cigars after rolling at room temperature and about 72% relative humidity. At this level of temperature and humidity, the three parts of the cigars are allowed to equalize in moisture content, to slowly, ever so slowly, dry down. So room temperature and 72% humidity will keep cigars over time and 73% humidity will keep cigars perfect forever.

As the temperature gets lower, the humidity has to get higher to keep the cigars fresh. Never let the temperature get high. High temperature and high humidity create an incubator atmosphere and before you know it, the will be little bugs flying around to ruin your entire selection or a white mold will develop, or both. Dry cigars have less flavor and aroma, are less mild and flake off in the mouth. Dryness is the major cause of unraveling wrappers, the second most frequent complaint among premium cigar smokers.

So when you purchase that box of cigars for smoking (testing), make sure your source has kept them properly. Otherwise, if they're not in good condition, you'll never be able to tell if they're good or not good, consistent or inconsistent.


Is The Size Of A Cigar Important To The Taste And Aroma?

In general, a cigar smoker likes a particular size. So when considering the quality and consistency of taste and aroma of a cigar, unless you're smoking the size you're accustomed to, your sense of comparability is liable to be thrown off and it will be difficult to judge that cigar fairly. In other words, the same cigar blends in different sizes taste different - if there's a big difference in ring size and length. This because a big ring gauge, say 50 or 52, produces an immense volume of smoke compared to a 28, 36 or even a 42 ring*. Naturally, taste and aroma are strongly influenced by this.

To a lesser extent, length also influences taste, but not so seriously as ring size. Besides, if you start with a 7 inch cigar when you're used to one 5 1/2 inches long, it'll become 5 1/2 inches long soon anyway - although, believe it or not, the 7 inch cigar at 5 1/2 inches will taste a little different than the one that starts at 5 1/2 inches.

Thus, if a manufacturer excels at making a great cigar 42 ring x 6 1/2 inches, it does not necessarily follow that the same brand in other sizes will be as good or as consistent. You'll have to try a box of each. But if you're not accustomed to smoking a certain size that you might be curious about, maybe you should enlist the cooperation of a friend who does smoke that size regularly.<

* 1 Ring = 1/64" in diameter, thus a 50 ring cigar is a bit more than 3/4" in diameter.


What About Price?

Is the price of a cigar indicative of its quality or its consistency?

Regardless of the price, you still have to smoke those 25 cigars in order to determine consistency. High prices do not guarantee a good cigar. The highest priced cigars are still hand made products, subject to the same construction idiosyncrasies as their less expensive brethren.

Generally, the biggest element of cost in the make up of a fine cigar is the tobacco, assuming they're packed in the common type of box. Fancy packaging can add greatly to the overall cost. Individual aluminum or glass tubes, polished or beveled cedar or mahogany boxes, gift selections of 5 or 10 cigars, etc. are very expensive and significantly increase the price of the individual cigar

So, we find prices varying greatly. Some cigars cost 8 or 10 times more than others of the same size and it's the smoker's dilemma to judge their relative worth. And we all know how the price of an object can affect our psyche and thus our attitude towards it. So, as far as how much you're prepared to pay for a cigar is concerned, practice a bit of caveat emptor and you'll be all right. Whatever you pay, you'll still have to go through the same analysis to determine just how good the cigars are.


EPILOGUE

We hope this little piece of information on how to judge a "good" cigar helps you in your search for excellence. At the very least, we trust that you now understand why you can't test one cigar and from that singular experience label it "good", or even not so "good". Notice, we have not tried to tell you how a cigar should taste or smell. That's too personal. As a rule, with cigars as with food and wine, if you like the taste and aroma, it's good. And, if that pleasing taste and aroma is delivered every time, then the cigar is "good." But, if you personally do not enjoy the taste of a particular cigar but find all the other aspects of it to be sound, it might be considered "good" by another person. It's something akin to all those people in the world who do not enjoy caviar. The subjectivity of taste is one of life's fascinations and it definitely applies to cigars, as well as caviar.

Enjoy.

Used with permission from Altadis U.S.A. Inc.



Go back to Volume I




 

       




Contents Copyright 2010 Altadis U.S.A. Inc.


created by www.Paradise-Multimedia.com